Fine-tuning LLMs and AI models

Large language models (LLMs) are powerful tools that can help with a lot of different tasks, from writing emails to answering complex questions. But sometimes, these models don't quite understand what you need them to do for your specific project. That's where fine-tuning comes in. It's like teaching a smart student the specific skills they need for a particular job.

Fine tuning Gemini with Google AI Studio

What is fine-tuning?

Fine-tuning involves further training a pre-trained LLM on a task-specific dataset (a transfer learning process). Think of it like this: a pre-trained model has already learned a lot of general information, and fine-tuning helps it specialize in a particular area.

When to fine-tune versus using RAG

Fine-tuning and Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) are two different ways to adjust LLMs for specific uses. Picking the right method depends on factors like the kind of task, if you have enough data, and what you want to achieve.

Technique


Main difference


Advantages

Challenges

Fine-tuning

Alters the model's parameter.

Improved accuracy, enhanced specificity, reduced hallucinations, customized interactions, cost-effectiveness, reduced bias.

Risk of "catastrophic forgetting", higher resource cost, stronger data demands, and potential for "overfitting".

RAG


Augments prompts with external knowledge.

Dynamic knowledge integration, contextual relevance, versatility, reduced need for extensive training.

Limited accuracy (for example, RAG can only reference the data it has access to, and doesn't make inferences based on its training), complexity of maintaining RAG systems, potential for hallucinations.

Technique


Main difference


Advantages

Challenges

Fine-tuning

Alters the model's parameter.

Improved accuracy, enhanced specificity, reduced hallucinations, customized interactions, cost-effectiveness, reduced bias.

Risk of "catastrophic forgetting", higher resource cost, stronger data demands, and potential for "overfitting".

RAG


Augments prompts with external knowledge.

Dynamic knowledge integration, contextual relevance, versatility, reduced need for extensive training.

Limited accuracy (for example, RAG can only reference the data it has access to, and doesn't make inferences based on its training), complexity of maintaining RAG systems, potential for hallucinations.

You should consider fine-tuning when you want an LLM to:

  • Understand specific language or jargon: If your project uses a lot of industry-specific terms, fine-tuning can help the model learn and use that language correctly  
  • Improve accuracy on a particular task: Fine-tuning can significantly improve the model's performance if you need it to do a specific task, like classifying customer reviews or generating product descriptions 
  • Match a particular style or tone: If you want the model to generate text that matches a specific brand voice or writing style, fine-tuning can help  
  • Work with limited data: When you have limited data, fine-tuning can be more efficient than training a model from scratch because it leverages the knowledge the pre-trained model already has  
  • Reduce costs and latency: For high-volume use cases, fine-tuning a smaller model can be more cost-effective than using a larger, general-purpose model for each request
  • Handle edge cases: Fine-tuning can improve the model's ability to handle edge cases and complex prompts that are difficult to address through prompt engineering alone

How fine-tuning works: a step-by-step guide

Fine-tuning builds upon the foundation of a pre-trained LLM. These pre-trained models have already learned a huge amount of general language knowledge from massive datasets. During fine-tuning, the model is exposed to a smaller, task-specific dataset, and the model's internal parameters—think of them as millions of tiny knobs that control its knowledge—are adjusted to better match the examples in the new dataset. This "retraining" process gently updates the model’s internal wiring so it becomes an expert on the new topic. Let’s break down the fine-tuning process into a few practical steps:

Step 1: Data preparation

Before you can begin fine-tuning, it's crucial to prepare your data. The quality and structure of your data directly impact the performance of the fine-tuned model. This stage involves collecting, cleaning, formatting, and splitting your data into appropriate sets for training, validation, and testing.

  • Collect data: Gather the data you'll use to fine-tune the model; this data should be relevant to the specific task you want the model to excel at
  • Clean and format: Clean your data by removing errors, inconsistencies, and irrelevant information; ensure it's in a format the model can understand
  • Split data: Divide your data into three sets: 1.) training (used to train the model), 2.) validation (used to monitor the model's performance and adjust settings), and 3.) test (used to evaluate the final performance of the fine-tuned model)

Step 2: Choosing an approach

When it comes to fine-tuning, you have options on how much of the pre-trained model you want to adjust. The approach you choose depends on factors like the size of your dataset, the computing resources available, and the desired level of accuracy. The two main approaches are full fine-tuning and parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT).


Full fine-tuning

In full fine-tuning, all the model's parameters are updated during training. This approach is suitable when the task-specific dataset is large and significantly different from the pre-training data.  


PEFT 

Parameter-efficient fine-tuning offers a smarter, more efficient way to fine-tune. Instead of retraining the entire model (which is slow and expensive), PEFT methods freeze the original LLM and add tiny new, trainable layers.

Think of it like this: Instead of rewriting an entire 1,000-page textbook, you just add a few pages of sticky notes with the new, specialized information. This makes the process dramatically faster and cheaper. Popular PEFT methods include LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) and QLoRA (Quantized Low-Rank Adaptation), offering a more efficient way to fine-tune LLMs. 

Step 3: Training the model

With your data prepared and your technique selected, it's time to train the model. This is where the model learns from your data and adjusts its parameters to improve performance on your specific task. Careful monitoring and adjustment of training settings are essential for achieving optimal results.

  • Set hyperparameters: Configure settings like learning rate, batch size, and number of epochs; these settings help control how the model learns
  • Start training: Feed the training data into the model and let it learn; monitor the model's performance using the validation set
  • Adjust as needed: If the model isn't performing well, you can adjust the hyperparameters or try a different fine-tuning technique

Step 4: Evaluation and deployment

The final stage involves evaluating the performance of your fine-tuned model and deploying it for real-world use. This requires assessing its accuracy and efficiency, and then integrating it into your application or system. Continuous monitoring and retraining may be necessary to maintain optimal performance over time.

  • Evaluate performance: Use the test set to evaluate the final performance of the fine-tuned model; look at metrics relevant to your task, such as accuracy, precision, and recall
  • Deploy the model: If you're happy with the performance, deploy the model to your application or system
  • Monitor performance: Keep an eye on the model's performance in the real world and retrain it as needed to maintain accuracy

Types of fine-tuning

There are different ways to fine-tune a model, depending on your goals and resources:

Type

Description

Use cases

Supervised fine-tuning

The model is trained on a labeled dataset with input-output pairs.

Text classification, named entity recognition, sentiment analysis.

Instruction fine-tuning

The model is trained on a dataset of instructions and desired responses.

Chatbots, question answering systems, code generation.

Few-shot learning

The model is provided with a few examples of the desired task within the prompt.

Adapting to new tasks with limited data.

Transfer learning

The model leverages knowledge gained from pre-training on a general-purpose dataset.

Adapting to related tasks.

Domain-specific fine-tuning

The model is adapted to a particular domain or industry.

Legal document analysis, medical report generation, financial forecasting.

Multi-task learning

The model is trained on multiple tasks simultaneously.

Improving performance across related tasks.

Sequential fine-tuning

The model is adapted to a series of related tasks in stages.

Gradually refining capabilities for complex tasks.

Type

Description

Use cases

Supervised fine-tuning

The model is trained on a labeled dataset with input-output pairs.

Text classification, named entity recognition, sentiment analysis.

Instruction fine-tuning

The model is trained on a dataset of instructions and desired responses.

Chatbots, question answering systems, code generation.

Few-shot learning

The model is provided with a few examples of the desired task within the prompt.

Adapting to new tasks with limited data.

Transfer learning

The model leverages knowledge gained from pre-training on a general-purpose dataset.

Adapting to related tasks.

Domain-specific fine-tuning

The model is adapted to a particular domain or industry.

Legal document analysis, medical report generation, financial forecasting.

Multi-task learning

The model is trained on multiple tasks simultaneously.

Improving performance across related tasks.

Sequential fine-tuning

The model is adapted to a series of related tasks in stages.

Gradually refining capabilities for complex tasks.

Best practices for fine-tuning

To get the most out of fine-tuning, follow these best practices :  

  • Data quality and quantity: Use a high-quality dataset that is relevant, diverse, and sufficiently large. Data quality is paramount in fine-tuning. Ensure the data is accurate, consistent, and free of errors or biases. For example, a dataset with noisy labels or inconsistent formatting can significantly hinder the model's ability to learn effectively.   
  • Hyperparameter tuning: Experiment with different hyperparameter settings to find the optimal configuration for your task.   
  • Regular evaluation: Regularly evaluate the model's performance during training to track its progress and make necessary adjustments.   
  • Avoid overfitting: Use techniques like early stopping and regularization to prevent overfitting to the training data.   
  • Address bias: Be mindful of potential biases in the data and use techniques to mitigate bias in the fine-tuned model.

Benefits of fine-tuning LLMs

Fine-tuning offers a few potential advantages:

Improved accuracy

It can significantly improve the accuracy and relevance of the model's output for your specific use case, potentially reducing AI hallucinations.  

Faster training

Fine-tuning is faster and requires less data than training a model from scratch.

Cost-effective

It can be more cost-effective than training a new model because it requires less computing power and data. 

Customization

Fine-tuning allows you to customize the model's behavior to align with your specific needs and goals. 

Reduced bias

It can provide better control over the model's behavior, potentially reducing the risk of generating biased or controversial content.

Increased context window

Fine-tuning can be used to increase the context window of LLMs, allowing them to process and retain more information.

Common challenges when fine-tuning

While fine-tuning can offer many benefits, there are also some possible challenges to be aware of: 

  • Overfitting: The model learns the training data too well and does not generalize well to new data. You can use techniques like regularization and data augmentation to mitigate overfitting.  
  • Data scarcity: Insufficient data can limit the effectiveness of fine-tuning. Consider using data augmentation techniques or transfer learning from other related tasks.  
  • Catastrophic forgetting: If you specialize the model too narrowly, it can forget its general knowledge. It’s like an expert doctor who becomes a hyper-specialized surgeon but forgets basic first aid. You can use techniques like regularization and replay buffers to mitigate catastrophic forgetting.  
  • Computational resources: Fine-tuning large models can be computationally expensive and require significant memory. Consider using techniques like PEFT, quantization, and distributed training to reduce computational requirements.  
  • Evaluation: Evaluating the performance of fine-tuned LLMs can be complex, requiring careful selection of metrics and benchmarks.  
  • Multi-task learning challenges: Fine-tuning LLMs for multi-task learning introduces unique challenges, such as task interference, where different objectives clash during training, and data imbalance, where tasks with more data may dominate.

Fine-tuning use cases

Fine-tuning can be applied to a wide range of use cases:

Customer service

Fine-tune an LLM to understand and respond to customer inquiries more effectively, including within chatbots.  

The ability of LLMs to generate concise and accurate summaries in specific domains or writing styles can be improved through fine-tuning.

Content creation

Create blog posts, articles, or product descriptions in a specific style with a fine-tuned model.  

Data analysis

Fine-tune a model to classify and analyze text data, such as social media posts or customer reviews.

Generate code in a specific programming language or framework with a fine-tuned model. 

Machine translation

Google Translate uses fine-tuning to improve the quality of machine translation by adapting the model to specific language pairs and domains. 

Fine-tuning at scale with Google Cloud

Google Cloud offers a robust ecosystem to support your model fine-tuning efforts, providing everything from a unified machine learning platform to the specialized hardware needed to accelerate complex computations. Whether you're customizing a foundation model or refining your own, these services streamline the entire workflow.

Take the next step

Start building on Google Cloud with $300 in free credits and 20+ always free products.

Google Cloud